The Driller
  • Sign In
  • Create Account
  • Sign Out
  • My Account
  • NEWS
  • CLASSIFIEDS
  • EQUIPMENT
  • SAFETY
  • VIDEOS
  • EDUCATION
  • SOURCEBOOK
  • EVENTS
  • SUBMIT
  • ABOUT
  • SIGN UP
cart
facebook twitter linkedin youtube
  • NEWS
  • Water
  • Geothermal
  • Construction
  • Environmental
  • Mining
  • All Industry News
  • EQUIPMENT
  • Rigs & Heavy Equipment
  • Consumables
  • Pumps
  • Featured Products
  • VIDEOS
  • Newscast
  • Drill Talks
  • Ask Brock
  • Emerging Drillers
  • EDUCATION
  • Drilling Business Insights
  • Reference Desk
  • Sponsored Insights
  • EVENTS
  • Conferences & Demo Days
  • Newscast LIVE
  • SUBMIT
  • Drillers @Work
  • ABOUT
  • Contact
  • Advertise
The Driller
search
cart
facebook twitter linkedin youtube
  • Sign In
  • Create Account
  • Sign Out
  • My Account
The Driller
  • NEWS
    • Water
    • Geothermal
    • Construction
    • Environmental
    • Mining
    • All Industry News
  • CLASSIFIEDS
  • EQUIPMENT
    • Rigs & Heavy Equipment
    • Consumables
    • Pumps
    • Featured Products
  • SAFETY
  • VIDEOS
    • Newscast
    • Drill Talks
    • Ask Brock
    • Emerging Drillers
  • EDUCATION
    • Drilling Business Insights
    • Reference Desk
    • Sponsored Insights
  • SOURCEBOOK
  • EVENTS
    • Conferences & Demo Days
    • Newscast LIVE
  • SUBMIT
    • Drillers @Work
  • ABOUT
    • Contact
    • Advertise
  • SIGN UP
MarketsEquipmentOpinionsWater WellsSchmitt's 'Let Me Tell Ya'Drill Rigs & Heavy Equipment

One Man's Opinion – Two Weak Points of the Bucyrus-Erie 20W

Power Unit, Mast on Old Rig Made Hole, but Could Have been Better

By John Schmitt
Bucyrus-Erie 20W

Columnist John Schmitt ran a Bucyrus-Erie 20W like this for many years, and says the spudder was a moneymaker and workhorse despite a few design flaws.

Source: Dean Dickover

December 21, 2020

From comments I have received there is still interest in cable tool drilling and cable tool rigs. Certainly, these rigs have nowhere near the popularity they once did. The rigs and the cable-tool method of drilling have become almost mysterious, judging from what I have heard. So I plan to write a couple more columns about the old, old Bucyrus-Erie 20W I had years ago. 

The 20W rig had a quality design and build. This was not by accident. The Bucyrus-Erie line extended and advanced the Armstrong Drill line, which went back many years. As I have written, Bucyrus-Erie bought out Armstrong Drill in the 1930s and about 1943 dropped the Armstrong name and built the rigs as Bucyrus-Erie. Despite good design and build, the 20W had a couple of weak points: the power unit and the mast. 


Powering the 20W Spudder

Articles in This Series

  • Making the Decision to Buy a Used Water Well Rig
  • In Detail: Columnist John Schmitt’s First Bucyrus Erie 20W
  • In Detail: How Did Reels on an Old Spudder Rig Work?
  • In Detail: How Did the Spudder on an Old Drilling Rig Work?
  • One Man's Opinion – Two Weak Points of the Bucyrus-Erie 20W
  • Mounting Options for a Bucyrus-Erie 20W (or Any Spudder)

The 20W I purchased used was powered by a 4-cylinder Hercules Model IXA gasoline engine. Hercules built engines in Canton, Ohio. I don’t know if they are still in business. The IXA was a flathead engine with a displacement of about 113 cubic inches. Fuel was supplied from an overhead tank as I don’t believe this engine had a fuel pump. Ignition was by a magneto. When I bought the rig, it was crank started. This was not a bad deal, as it started rather easily in any weather — provided you had the right oil in the crankcase. The multi-grade oils of 2020 were unheard of. We ran straight grade 30 oil in the summer and 10 grade in the winter. If the weather turned quickly cold in the fall, you sometimes got caught with the wrong grade of oil, but that was not a big problem. Sometime after I bought this rig, I found a starter and generator for the engine. I built a battery box and now had an electric-start engine. Overall, the Hercules was a good engine.

This little engine had plenty of power for normal drilling. I remember seeing this rig run by its first owner, who bought it brand new. He was drilling a 6-inch well with heavy tools and the little Hercules seemed to do the job very well. The problem I encountered was with the carburetor. This engine had an updraft carburetor and, as I remember, its air came from an oil bath cleaner outside the engine house. Michigan winters often have dampness and humidity, causing the carburetor many times to ice up. This caused the engine to run at uneven speeds — slowing down then speeding up. Running cable tools effectively requires a smooth-running engine. If you open the side panel when this was happening you would see frost between the carburetor and the intake manifold. It was obvious some icing was occurring, much to the consternation of the driller. I have read this problem occurred in some aircraft engines of that era with great loss of power and disastrous results — a crash. I put up with this icing for a couple of winters and then got a bright thought. I was able to reroute the inlet to the air cleaner to a point inside the engine cover right over the head. This gave the engine warmer air to use and cut back on the icing to a great degree. When the weather warmed, I would replace this intake pipe to one that took its air from outside. The conversion was a simple job.

The engine house or cover had to be quite low to fit in the frame on the 20W, limiting upgrade options. If you wanted to go to a newer, more modern overhead-valve engine, you had to extend the frame. This presented all kinds of problems. However, in later years, Bucyrus-Erie did make the frame different so you could use a taller engine.

The little Hercules served me well for many years. Eventually, though, it just about wore out. It was the main reason I traded this rig for a newer-model 20W with a much more powerful engine. 


The Mast on the 20W

The second design flaw the 20W had, in my opinion, was the mast and its lack of strength. Early 20Ws had a 32-foot, one-piece mast made of steel in a box-like section. After a few years, Bucyrus-Erie offered the option of a 36-foot telescoping mast. My rig had this mast design, which I think later became standard. If you drilled small-diameter 3-, 4- and 5-inch wells, the 36-foot mast was none too high, and you really needed a 40-foot mast. Five-inch channel iron made up the lower section of the 36-foot mast. It was heavily braced on both sides with steel bars that ran 90 degrees to the length and diagonal bars between the crossbars. The upper section, while made from 4-inch channel iron and also well braced, was the problem. 

If your 20W had a casing reel — mine did — and you had strung up a two-part line you could lift about 6,700 pounds. A two-part line, of course, had a traveling block with one sheave. I think the manufacturer really intended the casing reel to lift sections of casing into a vertical position to attach to the string, or to lower strings of casing into the drill hole for grouting or another purpose. Most 20W operators I know used the casing line to pull casing driven into the ground or assist in pulling when bumping back casing. If you got a hold of a casing that was really tight in the ground and fully engage the casing reel clutch, even at part throttle, on the engine you could kink or severally bend the upper section of the mast. When I bought this rig used, it came with a bunch of tools and a spare (but ruined) upper mast section. The former owner said he had pulled hard and the mast just bent over.

Apparently, this owner had replaced the bent section and then bent slightly the replacement section. When my dad and I bought the rig, the bend in the upper section presented somewhat of a problem. Years later, we cleaned and painted the rig, which it needed badly. We took the mast apart and had that upper section straightened at a good welding shop. After we put it back together, we put a lot more care into how much load we applied to the casing line.

This aspect of the 20W needed improvement, and almost every owner of a 20W I have talked to agrees. The Speedstar 55, the 20W’s close competitor, featured an upper mast section the same size as the lower section. Drillers I knew who owned both told me the stronger mast on the 55 made it a much better rig than a 20W. I don’t think that this improvement was ever done to a 20W, although I haven’t seen a new one — now built by Buckeye Drill of Ohio — in many years. The poor mast design of the 20W did not detract from it being a solid, money-making rig.

We had a mild fall in Michigan and, as I write this in early December, my infamous lawn has gone from lush green to kind of a dead grey. It is, of course, dormant. I converted my trusty John Deere lawn tractor into my trusty John Deere snow plow — ready for the white stuff we know is coming.

It may well be 2021 by the time you read this, and we will be in the midst of winter here in the northern parts of the United States. Hopefully, the Covid-19 crisis will have improved. This dreaded affliction hit home this week for me when the wife of a dear friend and retired well driller died after contracting Covid-19 in the hospital where she went for a back repair. You have our sympathy, Dick.

Until next time, work safe and live safe so that you don’t come up with the dreaded Covid-19.


For more John Schmitt columns, visit www.thedriller.com/schmitt.

KEYWORDS: cable tool drilling water well drilling

Share This Story

Looking for a reprint of this article?
From high-res PDFs to custom plaques, order your copy today!

John schmitt 200px
John Schmitt is a former Certified Well Driller/Pump Installer with decades of water well experience.

Recommended Content

JOIN TODAY
to unlock your recommendations.

Already have an account? Sign In

  • geotechnical drilling rig

    6 Onsite Phrases Environmental Drillers Hate

    Here are six phrases that highlight common frustrations...
    Opinions
    By: Jeff Garby
  • Wayne Nash

    Pipe Stuck? Common Causes and Solutions for Drillers

    If you have drilled for any length of time, sooner or...
    Markets
    By: Wayne Nash
  • submersible pumps, water well pumps

    Selecting and Sizing Submersible Pump Cable

    This article helps pump installers and servicers decide...
    Equipment
    By: Bob Pelikan
You must login or register in order to post a comment.

Report Abusive Comment

Subscribe For Free!
  • eNewsletters
  • Online Registration
  • Subscription Customer Service
  • Manage My Preferences

The Driller Newscast, Episode 147: Global Geothermal Collaboration at NY-GEO 2025

The Driller Newscast, Episode 147: Global Geothermal Collaboration at NY-GEO 2025

The Driller Newscast: New York Geo Talks 2025 Conference with Hands-on Driller Education

The Driller Newscast: New York Geo Talks 2025 Conference with Hands-on Driller Education

The Driller Newscast: 21st Century Drillers | Part 1 DEMAND

The Driller Newscast: 21st Century Drillers | Part 1 DEMAND

The Driller Newscast: Coiled Tubing Drilling and the Future of Geothermal

The Driller Newscast: Coiled Tubing Drilling and the Future of Geothermal

More Videos

Sponsored Content

Sponsored Content is a special paid section where industry companies provide high quality, objective, non-commercial content around topics of interest to the The Driller audience. All Sponsored Content is supplied by the advertising company and any opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and not necessarily reflect the views of The Driller or its parent company, BNP Media. Interested in participating in our Sponsored Content section? Contact your local rep!

close
  • demo of a DM450 drilling rig during a customer factory visit
    Sponsored byGeoprobe

    Built for You: Smarter Drill Rigs, Stronger Support, Bigger Opportunities

Popular Stories

MainPhotoTwoBrothers.jpg

Two Brothers' Journey Through the Drilling Industry

demo of a DM450 drilling rig during a customer factory visit

Built for You: Smarter Drill Rigs, Stronger Support, Bigger Opportunities

AI and Drought Concerns

AI’s Growing Thirst for Water and Power

The Driller Classifieds

COMPRESSORS

EAST WEST MACHINERY & DRILLING IS BUYING AND SELLING AIR COMPRESSORS, AIR BOOSTERS, AIR ENDS & PARTS
Company: East West Machinery

DRILL RIGS

LOOKING FOR LATE MODEL TOPHEADS & DRILLTECH D25'S
Company: Spikes’s Rig Sales

DRILL RIG PARTS

MEETING DRILLERS NEEDS AROUND THE WORLD
Company: East West Machinery

ELEVATORS

SEMCO INC. PIPE ELEVATORS
Company: Semco Inc.

GROUTERS

GROUTING EQUIPMENT - GROUT PUMPS & GROUT HOSE REELS
Company: Geo-Loop Inc.

PUMP HOISTS

SEMCO INC. - BASIC PUMP HOISTS
Company: Semco Inc.

WELL PACKERS

LANSAS PRODUCTS - INFLATABLE WELL PACKERS
Company: Vanderlans Lansas Products

WELL SCREENS

WELL SCREENS & SLOTTED PIPE
Company: Alloy Screen Works

Products

Water Quality Engineering: Physical / Chemical Treatment Processes

Water Quality Engineering: Physical / Chemical Treatment Processes

By carefully explaining both the underlying theory and the underlying mathematics, this text enables readers to fully grasp the fundamentals of physical and chemical treatment processes for water and wastewater.

See More Products

Subscribe to The Driller Newscast

Related Articles

  • John Schmitt

    Mounting Options for a Bucyrus-Erie 20W (or Any Spudder)

    See More
  • John Schmitt

    In Detail: Columnist John Schmitt’s First Bucyrus Erie 20W

    See More
  • John Schmitt

    In Detail: How Did the Spudder on an Old Drilling Rig Work?

    See More

Related Products

See More Products
  • 1119083621.jpg

    Formulas and Calculations for Drilling Operations, 2nd Edition

  • 9780128034170.jpg

    Formulas and Calculations for Drilling, Production, and Workover, 4th Edition

See More Products
×

Dig deeper into the drilling and water supply industry!

Build your knowledge with The Driller, covering the people, equipment and technologies across drilling markets.

SIGN UP NOW
  • RESOURCES
    • Advertise
    • Contact Us
    • Directories
    • Store
    • Want More
    • Classifieds
  • SIGN UP TODAY
    • Create Account
    • eNewsletters
    • Customer Service
    • Manage Preferences
  • SERVICES
    • Marketing Services
    • Reprints
    • Market Research
    • List Rental
    • Survey/Respondent Access
  • STAY CONNECTED
    • LinkedIn
    • Facebook
    • YouTube
    • X (Twitter)
  • PRIVACY
    • PRIVACY POLICY
    • TERMS & CONDITIONS
    • DO NOT SELL MY PERSONAL INFORMATION
    • PRIVACY REQUEST
    • ACCESSIBILITY

Copyright ©2025. All Rights Reserved BNP Media.

Design, CMS, Hosting & Web Development :: ePublishing

The Driller
search
cart
facebook twitter linkedin youtube
  • Sign In
  • Create Account
  • Sign Out
  • My Account
The Driller
  • NEWS
    • Water
    • Geothermal
    • Construction
    • Environmental
    • Mining
    • All Industry News
  • CLASSIFIEDS
  • EQUIPMENT
    • Rigs & Heavy Equipment
    • Consumables
    • Pumps
    • Featured Products
  • SAFETY
  • VIDEOS
    • Newscast
    • Drill Talks
    • Ask Brock
    • Emerging Drillers
  • EDUCATION
    • Drilling Business Insights
    • Reference Desk
    • Sponsored Insights
  • SOURCEBOOK
  • EVENTS
    • Conferences & Demo Days
    • Newscast LIVE
  • SUBMIT
    • Drillers @Work
  • ABOUT
    • Contact
    • Advertise
  • SIGN UP