The Driller
  • Sign In
  • Create Account
  • Sign Out
  • My Account
  • NEWS
  • CLASSIFIEDS
  • EQUIPMENT
  • SAFETY
  • VIDEOS
  • EDUCATION
  • SOURCEBOOK
  • EVENTS
  • SUBMIT
  • ABOUT
  • SIGN UP
cart
facebook twitter linkedin youtube
  • NEWS
  • Water
  • Geothermal
  • Construction
  • Environmental
  • Mining
  • All Industry News
  • EQUIPMENT
  • Rigs & Heavy Equipment
  • Consumables
  • Pumps
  • Featured Products
  • VIDEOS
  • Newscast
  • Drill Talks
  • Ask Brock
  • Emerging Drillers
  • EDUCATION
  • Drilling Business Insights
  • Reference Desk
  • Sponsored Insights
  • EVENTS
  • Conferences & Demo Days
  • Newscast LIVE
  • SUBMIT
  • Drillers @Work
  • ABOUT
  • Contact
  • Advertise
The Driller
search
cart
facebook twitter linkedin youtube
  • Sign In
  • Create Account
  • Sign Out
  • My Account
The Driller
  • NEWS
    • Water
    • Geothermal
    • Construction
    • Environmental
    • Mining
    • All Industry News
  • CLASSIFIEDS
  • EQUIPMENT
    • Rigs & Heavy Equipment
    • Consumables
    • Pumps
    • Featured Products
  • SAFETY
  • VIDEOS
    • Newscast
    • Drill Talks
    • Ask Brock
    • Emerging Drillers
  • EDUCATION
    • Drilling Business Insights
    • Reference Desk
    • Sponsored Insights
  • SOURCEBOOK
  • EVENTS
    • Conferences & Demo Days
    • Newscast LIVE
  • SUBMIT
    • Drillers @Work
  • ABOUT
    • Contact
    • Advertise
  • SIGN UP
MarketsEquipmentOpinionsWater WellsSchmitt's 'Let Me Tell Ya'Drilling Consumables

What Are Pros, Cons of Green Sand Iron Filters?

By John Schmitt
potassium permanganate

As the container plainly indicates, potassium permanganate is pretty nasty stuff.

Source: Lukasz Katlewa / Wikimedia Commons

July 12, 2019

In my next to last article, I said I would next discuss regenerating green sand-type iron filters. So, let’s get to it.

It’s been a few years since I’ve done one of these, or even instructed a customer in how to do it. As I recall, this process was not a lot of fun. In fact, it was no fun at all.

The earliest green sand-type filters I sold were one-tank models. They had a multi-position, rotary-style valve to put the units through their various processes. This valve had a single handle that rotated 180 degrees or more to accomplish the regeneration. The regeneration process itself was strictly manual and started with — you guessed it — a reversal of the flow pattern to flush to drain the accumulated iron. The next step was to add the “not pleasant” potassium permanganate (PP) and let it slowly seep through the green sand. The final step was to flush the excess PP in the normal flow direction.

While all this was going on, the person doing the regenerating had to be pretty much standing by. As I recall, there was a prescribed time to do each of the three processes, so the person doing the regenerating had to have a good watch or perhaps a timer. To add the dreaded PP, the filter was depressurized and a large cap at the top was opened. This cap usually had an O-ring, and although it could be a leaker it hardly ever was. A measured amount of PP was then added to the tank. Of course to make room for this PP, the tank had to be drained slightly using a drain valve at its bottom. I remember that the PP could be added in solid form, but sometimes directions recommended mixing it in a small pail and adding as a solution. This mixing was really messy and if you got some PP or the PP solution on your hands or any other surface, it would stain badly. 

The seeping of the PP solution through the mineral bed was also a timed item. Then the unit was flushed. Flushing continued until water coming out of the unit was clear. Pink water meant the unit needed further flushing. The handy bottom valve was a good place to check the appearance of the outlet water. The unit was then ready for service. But heaven forbid if the person doing the regeneration forgot to open the bypass valve. This would allow PP-laden water into the piping system.

The good news was that this regeneration did not have to be done as frequently as a water softener regeneration. If the owner was really diligent in doing these regenerations, these green sand units worked quite well. I had one customer who was a professional (a dentist) and he was very punctual about regenerating his unit. His worked very well for many years. The fact that his wife would have a royal fit if they had anything but iron-free water may have motivated him.

One downside to these green sand filters was that the backflow needed to be considerably faster than the service flow. In some homes, there was just not enough pump capacity to do an adequate back flush. Another major downside was that the mineral bed had a tendency to channel. That is, the water somehow found a way to get through a hole in the bed or at least use the same path all the time, making the bed very inefficient.

As you have probably figured out, doing this regeneration in a home setting in the busy, busy, busy days of 2019 would be an absolute no-no. In a commercial or industrial setting where a licensed plant operator was in charge of this process, it would work quite well. These single-tank green sand filters are, I believe, a thing of the past in domestic applications and I will say that is a very good thing.

Staying with the green sand as a media, some manufacturers later came out with semi-automatic iron filters. These were just like the single-tank units but with a reserve tank, or “brine” tank, if you will. This brine tank was sometimes nothing more than a good quality five-gallon bucket with a lid on it. The liquid level was manually controlled through the regeneration valve and, from time to time, the homeowner added some solid PP to make the “brine” effective.

Some of these units had a 1, 2, 3, 4 position manual valve, not unlike the early water softeners that had a lever like the gear shift on a car. However, the person doing the regeneration still had to keep track of the time of each cycle and the PP was still messy.

At one time you could buy potassium permanganate at some drug stores. Later, I believe you had to get it through the filter manufacturers. Safety precautions regarding the substance that I wrote about two columns back still applied.

I had one of these two-tank iron filters in my own home and, frankly, it never worked very well. I was quite disappointed with it. It was probably better than nothing, but not much. I think the nature of the green sand, the dreaded PP and the fact that most of these were manual or semi-manual combined to make these filters only semi-successful, at least in domestic settings. I will not comment on commercial or industrial uses, as I don’t think I ever sold one of those high-capacity units. Next time, I’ll write about some iron filters that came after the green sand models that were initially nothing special either, but eventually pretty darn good.

As I write this in the middle of May I have mowed my famous or infamous lawn three whole times, and it is looking very green and very good. To you folks in the South, you’re probably amazed at this statement. Our weather has generally been very cool, damp and windy with nighttime temperatures low enough to make our heat pump run at least for a while every night. If you still have to use potassium permanganate, you have my sympathy. If you don’t use it, be thankful.
 


For more John Schmitt columns, visit www.thedriller.com/schmitt.

KEYWORDS: water treatment water well drilling well drilling

Share This Story

Looking for a reprint of this article?
From high-res PDFs to custom plaques, order your copy today!

John schmitt 200px
John Schmitt is a former Certified Well Driller/Pump Installer with decades of water well experience.

Recommended Content

JOIN TODAY
to unlock your recommendations.

Already have an account? Sign In

  • geotechnical drilling rig

    6 Onsite Phrases Environmental Drillers Hate

    Here are six phrases that highlight common frustrations...
    The Underground Network
    By: Jeff Garby
  • Wayne Nash

    Pipe Stuck? Common Causes and Solutions for Drillers

    If you have drilled for any length of time, sooner or...
    Water Wells
    By: Wayne Nash
  • submersible pumps, water well pumps

    Selecting and Sizing Submersible Pump Cable

    This article helps pump installers and servicers decide...
    Markets
    By: Bob Pelikan
You must login or register in order to post a comment.

Greensand filters

bretallick0@gmail.com
March 7, 2020
What is the life expectancy of the greensand media in a typical residential system.

verduscoj@bnpmedia.com
March 9, 2020
We found this Q&A about green sand media helpful: https://www.watertreatmentguide.com/manganese_greensand.htm

Report Abusive Comment

Subscribe For Free!
  • eNewsletters
  • Online Registration
  • Subscription Customer Service
  • Manage My Preferences

The Driller Newscast: New York Geo Talks 2025 Conference with Hands-on Driller Education

The Driller Newscast: New York Geo Talks 2025 Conference with Hands-on Driller Education

The Driller Newscast, Episode 147: Global Geothermal Collaboration at NY-GEO 2025

The Driller Newscast, Episode 147: Global Geothermal Collaboration at NY-GEO 2025

The Driller Newscast: Coiled Tubing Drilling and the Future of Geothermal

The Driller Newscast: Coiled Tubing Drilling and the Future of Geothermal

The Driller Newscast: 21st Century Drillers | Part 1 DEMAND

The Driller Newscast: 21st Century Drillers | Part 1 DEMAND

More Videos

Sponsored Content

Sponsored Content is a special paid section where industry companies provide high quality, objective, non-commercial content around topics of interest to the The Driller audience. All Sponsored Content is supplied by the advertising company and any opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and not necessarily reflect the views of The Driller or its parent company, BNP Media. Interested in participating in our Sponsored Content section? Contact your local rep!

close
  • demo of a DM450 drilling rig during a customer factory visit
    Sponsored byGeoprobe

    Built for You: Smarter Drill Rigs, Stronger Support, Bigger Opportunities

Popular Stories

MainPhotoTwoBrothers.jpg

Two Brothers' Journey Through the Drilling Industry

demo of a DM450 drilling rig during a customer factory visit

Built for You: Smarter Drill Rigs, Stronger Support, Bigger Opportunities

AI and Drought Concerns

AI’s Growing Thirst for Water and Power

The Driller Classifieds

COMPRESSORS

EAST WEST MACHINERY & DRILLING IS BUYING AND SELLING AIR COMPRESSORS, AIR BOOSTERS, AIR ENDS & PARTS
Company: East West Machinery

DRILL RIGS

LOOKING FOR LATE MODEL TOPHEADS & DRILLTECH D25'S
Company: Spikes’s Rig Sales

DRILL RIG PARTS

MEETING DRILLERS NEEDS AROUND THE WORLD
Company: East West Machinery

ELEVATORS

SEMCO INC. PIPE ELEVATORS
Company: Semco Inc.

GROUTERS

GROUTING EQUIPMENT - GROUT PUMPS & GROUT HOSE REELS
Company: Geo-Loop Inc.

PUMP HOISTS

SEMCO INC. - BASIC PUMP HOISTS
Company: Semco Inc.

WELL PACKERS

LANSAS PRODUCTS - INFLATABLE WELL PACKERS
Company: Vanderlans Lansas Products

WELL SCREENS

WELL SCREENS & SLOTTED PIPE
Company: Alloy Screen Works

Products

Water Quality Engineering: Physical / Chemical Treatment Processes

Water Quality Engineering: Physical / Chemical Treatment Processes

By carefully explaining both the underlying theory and the underlying mathematics, this text enables readers to fully grasp the fundamentals of physical and chemical treatment processes for water and wastewater.

See More Products

Subscribe to The Driller Newscast

Related Articles

  • John Schmitt

    Iron Filters, from Green Sand to Oxygen

    See More
  • Jessica Alexander

    What Are the Pros, Cons of Traveling Drilling Work?

    See More
  • John Schmitt

    Are Silica Sand Filters Required for Water Softeners?

    See More

Events

View AllSubmit An Event
  • October 14, 2016

    Virginia Water Well Association's Fall Field Day 2016

    This year, we are looking forward to stepping back in time and seeing first-hand what it took to construct wells, tools and maintain them.
View AllSubmit An Event
×

Dig deeper into the drilling and water supply industry!

Build your knowledge with The Driller, covering the people, equipment and technologies across drilling markets.

SIGN UP NOW
  • RESOURCES
    • Advertise
    • Contact Us
    • Directories
    • Store
    • Want More
    • Classifieds
  • SIGN UP TODAY
    • Create Account
    • eNewsletters
    • Customer Service
    • Manage Preferences
  • SERVICES
    • Marketing Services
    • Reprints
    • Market Research
    • List Rental
    • Survey/Respondent Access
  • STAY CONNECTED
    • LinkedIn
    • Facebook
    • YouTube
    • X (Twitter)
  • PRIVACY
    • PRIVACY POLICY
    • TERMS & CONDITIONS
    • DO NOT SELL MY PERSONAL INFORMATION
    • PRIVACY REQUEST
    • ACCESSIBILITY

Copyright ©2025. All Rights Reserved BNP Media.

Design, CMS, Hosting & Web Development :: ePublishing

The Driller
search
cart
facebook twitter linkedin youtube
  • Sign In
  • Create Account
  • Sign Out
  • My Account
The Driller
  • NEWS
    • Water
    • Geothermal
    • Construction
    • Environmental
    • Mining
    • All Industry News
  • CLASSIFIEDS
  • EQUIPMENT
    • Rigs & Heavy Equipment
    • Consumables
    • Pumps
    • Featured Products
  • SAFETY
  • VIDEOS
    • Newscast
    • Drill Talks
    • Ask Brock
    • Emerging Drillers
  • EDUCATION
    • Drilling Business Insights
    • Reference Desk
    • Sponsored Insights
  • SOURCEBOOK
  • EVENTS
    • Conferences & Demo Days
    • Newscast LIVE
  • SUBMIT
    • Drillers @Work
  • ABOUT
    • Contact
    • Advertise
  • SIGN UP